The Pure Waters of Early England
In the early days of Anglo-Saxon England, the economy was based on simple barter and gift-giving. The Thames flowed clear and unpolluted by complex financial instruments. The Anglo-Saxons operated under a gift economy, where social bonds were reinforced through the exchange of goods and favors.
The Norman Conquest: Babylon Reaches England
The Norman Conquest of 1066 marked a significant turning point, as William the Conqueror brought with him not just an army, but also a group of Ashkenazi Jews from Rouen, Normandy. These Jewish financiers had already been permitted to practice usury in Normandy, a practice forbidden to Christians by Catholic doctrine.
William, recognizing the potential of this financial tool, had used the funds generated from usurious lending to finance his invasion of England. Upon his victory, he brought these moneylenders with him, introducing the waters of Babylon to the shores of England.
The Rise of Jewish Moneylenders
The Jews, as the king’s property, enjoyed royal protection and were allowed to practice moneylending, filling a crucial economic niche. This arrangement proved profitable for the Crown, as the king could heavily tax the Jewish community and seize their assets at will. However, it also sowed the seeds of resentment among the English population, who often found themselves indebted to Jewish moneylenders.
Growing Tensions and Expulsion
As the centuries passed, the waters of the Thames became increasingly muddied by these Babylonian practices. The Jewish community, though small, became an integral part of the English economy. Even religious institutions like Canterbury Cathedral Priory borrowed money from Jewish lenders.
King Edward I, facing mounting debts and political pressure, took drastic action. In 1275, he issued the Statute of Jewry, which outlawed usury and attempted to redirect Jews into other professions. However, this proved impractical, and tensions continued to rise. Finally, in 1290, Edward issued the Edict of Expulsion, forcing all Jews to leave England.
A Brief Return to Simpler Finance
For centuries after the expulsion, the Thames flowed relatively free from usurious practices. The tally stick system, introduced in the 12th century, served as an interest-free form of government debt. These wooden sticks, split lengthwise, recorded debts and circulated as a form of currency, providing an alternative to usurious lending practices.
The Return of Babylon
In 1656, during the Protectorate of Oliver Cromwell, Jews were readmitted to England. It’s crucial to note that the problem was not the Jewish people themselves, but rather the practice of usury that they had been used to facilitate over the years, circumventing Catholic doctrines against such lending.
The readmission of Jews under Cromwell marked a new era in English finance. The sophisticated banking practices they brought with them helped fuel England’s commercial revolution and its rise as a global power. However, it also reintroduced the potential for financial exploitation and inequality.
The Triumph of Babylonian Finance
The final triumph of Babylonian financial practices came with Jeremy Bentham’s “Defence of Usury” in 1787. This influential work argued against limits on interest rates, claiming that such restrictions hindered economic growth and innovation. Bentham’s ideas gained traction, leading to the gradual dismantling of usury laws and paving the way for the modern financial system.
The Industrial Revolution and Beyond
As England entered the Industrial Revolution, the once-clear waters of the Thames became literally and figuratively polluted. The unrestricted flow of capital fueled unprecedented economic growth but also led to vast inequalities and social upheaval. The Babylonian system of finance, with its complex instruments and focus on profit above all else, had fully merged with the English economy.
Conclusion
This convergence of financial traditions has left a lasting legacy. While it has undoubtedly contributed to economic growth and innovation, it has also led to recurring cycles of boom and bust, financial crises, and social inequality. As we navigate the complex waters of modern finance, the lessons from this convergence remain relevant, challenging us to find a balance between economic dynamism and social equity.
Naismith, R. (2012). Money and Power in Anglo-Saxon England: The Southern English Kingdoms, 757-865. Cambridge University Press.
Mundill, R. R. (2010). The King’s Jews: Money, Massacre and Exodus in Medieval England. Continuum.
Stow, K. R. (1992). Alienated Minority: The Jews of Medieval Latin Europe. Harvard University Press.
Roth, C. (1964). A History of the Jews in England. Clarendon Press.
Lipman, V. D. (1967). The Jews of Medieval Norwich. Jewish Historical Society of England.
Prestwich, M. (1997). Edward I. Yale University Press.
Baxter, W. T. (1989). Early accounting: The tally and checkerboard. The Accounting Historians Journal, 16(2), 43-83.
Katz, D. S. (1994). The Jews in the History of England, 1485-1850. Clarendon Press.
Endelman, T. M. (2002). The Jews of Britain, 1656 to 2000. University of California Press.
Bentham, J. (1787). Defence of Usury. Payne and Foss.
Ferguson, N. (2008). The Ascent of Money: A Financial History of the World. Penguin Press.
